Invasive Infertility Tests
June 8, 2008
| This FAQ was compiled by Rebecca Smith Waddell for the alt.infertility and misc.health.infertility usenet newsgroups.
For each test, there is a price range listed next to the test name, and a short description of the procedure. Please note that the prices listed are without insurance and reflect a very small sample. Following that you will find personal experiences that were posted to the newsgroups or sent to me via e-mail. I have tried to get permission from everyone to use their posts. I thank everyone who was willing to help with this! If you would like to contribute prices or your story, please fill out our form. Thank you! Also, many of the posts used are from outside the United States. In those cases I have added the country as a way of letting international readers know that the tests are largely the same in many countries. These aren’t really in any order other than being grouped into the categories of endometrial biopsy, hysterosalpingogram, hysteroscopy, laparoscopy, sonohysterogram, and dilation & curettage. It is important to note that women are more likely to submit stories if their experiences were unpleasant. I have been told on several occasions that this FAQ is unnecessarily frightening, but that really depends on how you read it. Both positive and negative stories are included — one should not focus only on the negative. One also should not expect to be one of the worst cases presented here, but it is still probably worth knowing what the possible complications are. In most cases, the anticipation and worry before a procedure is worse than the event and recovery. As hard as it is to do, most women will benefit from being knowledgeable about the procedures while also trying to remain calm about the possibilities. |
| Table of Contents |
Endometrial Biopsy (EMB)
- What is an endometrial biopsy and why is it needed?
- What should I expect when I have an endometrial biopsy? How will it feel?
- How does an endometrial biopsy compare to a hysterosalpingogram?
Which one is more uncomfortable?
Hysterosalpingogram (HSG)
- What is a hysterosalpingogram and why is it needed?
- What should I expect when I have a hysterosalpingogram? How will it feel?
- Will having a hysterosalpingogram effect my chances of getting pregnant?
If so why and for how long?
Sonohysterogram / Saline Ultrasound (SHG / Sono-HSG)
- What is a sonohysterogram and why is it needed?
- What is the difference between this sonohysterogram and a hysterosalpingogram?
- What should I expect when I have a sonohysterogram How will it feel? Will it help?
Hysteroscopy (HSC)
- What is a hysteroscopy and why is it needed?
- What should I expect when I have a hysteroscopy? How will it feel? Will it help?
Laparoscopy (lap)
- What is a laparoscopy and why is it needed?
- What should I expect when I have a laparoscopy? How will it feel?
- What are some tips for preparing for my laparoscopy?
- Should I expect the period after a laparoscopy to be different?
- What is the difference between a laparoscopy and a laparotomy?
Dilation & Curettage (D&C)
- What is a dilation & curettage and why is it needed?
- What should I expect when I have a dilation & curettage? How will it feel? Will it help?
| Endometrial Biopsy (EMB) - $75-$305 |
| Hysterosalpingogram (HSG) - $200-$700 |
What is a hysterosalpingogram and why is it needed? A hysterosalpingogram is where dye is injected into the uterus to look for anatomic problems, such as tube patency (if they are open), fibroids, polyps, or structural problems with the uterine cavity. This test is usually done in the first half of a woman’s cycle, between days 7-10. A small catheter is inserted through the cervix in order to inject the dye, or, in some places, a balloon catheter is used to push dye through the cervix without actially threading anything through it. You’ll be expected to turn a little as the doctor / radiologist takes pictures or views the process through something that looks a lot like an ultrasound. It should only last about 5 minutes. Some cramping and discomfort is common during the procedure and for a little while afterward. Also, some spotting is to be expected. Your doctor may prescribe antibiotics and suggest a painkiller be taken. Be sure to tell your doctor if you are allergic to shellfish. Women taking metformin (brand name Glucophage or GlucophageXR) should discuss whether the medication should be discontinued for a couple of days before the procedure. The hysterosalpingogram is usually better for checking whether tubes are open than the sonohysterogram, where the other is probably better for checking for fibroids and polyps. What should I expect when I have a hysterosalpingogram? How will it feel? I had my HSG on Wednesday and I would have to say it is somewhat uncomfortable, but not that bad. I’d liken it to period cramps that last about 5 minutes. I actually had very little problem while I was getting to watch the dye move through, but because of certain activities (including the power being out during all of this!!!!) I didn’t get to see the dye flow through both tubes. I was left on the table for a minute while the radiologist went to check the still films he took, and I started panicking a little. I was supposed to be able to have my DH in the room, but at the last minute he was kicked out so an extra tech with a flashlight could assist the doctor. So between my not being there and not having seen the dye move all the way through one of the tubes I tensed and that’s when I had the most cramping. When I relaxed, it let up (luckily my doctor is very calming). I did have some more cramping when I got up from the table, but it was all over before I finished dressing. I would say I easily could have gone back to work if I wanted to, and the day after the HSG I went hiking in the woods and along the rock-bound coast of Maine with no discomfort. For 2 weeks I have been so afraid of this day. This will be the day that will tell me if I have more obstacles ahead of me. I am scheduled to be at the Outpatient Diagnostic Center at Norfolk Sentara at 1230 today. I got to the hospital 15 minutes early and went to radiology. Ok so I had to find the right department. I found the correct department. Checked in with the receptionist after that we did the normal payment paperwork. I was shown to the waiting area. That was the longest wait of my life. I was scheduled for the procedure at 1245. It was 115 before I was sent to the dressing room. I was given a gown and a robe. I took the robe into the dressing room. It did not fit. I went in the closest room and asked for another gown. There was a nurse and a patient in there. Oops! But, I got another gown. The restroom I changed in was dirty but I did finally get changed. I stood in the dressing hall way waiting for some one for close to 10 minutes. Finally a nurse came to get me. She took me into the room and had me sit down. One of the doctors from the Jones Institute came over to do the HSG. He had me sign the form for the Jones Institute. I guess he had to make sure he got his money too. I had to laugh at that. The doctor was great and explained everything to me as it happened. I laid on a x-ray table and he inserted the speculum cold and uncomfortable not too bad. He pinched my cervix and that started the dull cramping. He got the tube in and pulled out the speculum. The cramping was very noticeable by then and I had to hold myself still so that I would not rock. The radiologist came in and the doctor from the Jones Institute injected the dye as the radiologist captured it on the film. I had to turn to the left and the right this took all of three minutes once the radiologist was in the room. The radiologist left and he removed the tube. At first I just laid there as the pain increased and it was accompanied by pressure on my rectum. I had never heard of that before. The doctor had the films on the screen and showed me each one. The films show that I have perfect tubes and a perfectly shaped uterus with no noticeable adhesions. The doctor left and I stayed there flat for a few seconds. The nurse said I could take my time. I did. I slowly sat up and I had to lie back down. Then I sat up again and leaned back down. I did this for a few seconds. One thing that helped a lot was an elevated butterfly position with my legs and leaning into the opening. For some reason that relieved the pressure. It was difficult to get to the restroom and change. I had minor spotting and had to take a vicadin after getting dressed. It felt a lot better to stand and walk than to sit. It has been 10 hours and there is still minor cramping and the bleeding has stopped. Over all the procedure was not horrible but I would not want to do it every cycle. I had HSG done twice. In the first one (before my surgery for a fibroid) one of my tubes had minimal passage. Also the radiologist was somewhat harsh. I felt very uncomfortable and had severe discomfort in my stomach (actually did -sorry- threw up) after the HSG. In the second one the blocking on my tube had gone after the operation, and my OB performed it herself. She is very nice. I had mild discomfort, and if I had not had the bad experience the first time, I would not mind at all. I was told the solution they inject may be different on each occasion and that may also make a difference. BTW, all this took place abroad, it may be easier here. I just had one done last week. I’m the world’s biggest coward when it comes to medical procedures, and it didn’t help that my Dr went on and on about how painful it is. But I took about 3 Ibuprofen and it was fine — just mild cramping. My dh came with me and got me involved in a conversation to distract me — this helped a lot too, I think. I had an HSG, they found my tubes were clear - but I had a lot of pain during the procedure. It was worse than very bad cramps and I felt light headed during and immediately after the procedure. I wish someone had warned me it could be that bad - but I know it’s not the same for everyone. My gyno prescribed antibiotics ahead of time, and taking Advil may help a little as well (before and after). I had one in April—for me it was very painful, BUT only for five minutes (I may have a blocked tube, which they say makes it more painful—but, because it was so painful they can’t be sure my tube was blocked because I may have had a muscle spasm which blocked the dye.) good news—I didn’t feel any pain as soon as it was finished (unlike endometrial biopsy) Well, yesterday I had my HSG. I tried to stay as calm as possible, knowing that I had had a painkiller, that it could hurt very much or not at all and that I wanted to know the results badly. But because my tubes were infected twice (10 years ago) I was pretty much convinced that my tubes were blocked, and that would make the procedure more painful…… I just hoped that it wouldn’t be too bad, and that it would clearly show that though my tubes were blocked my womb was ok (as a DES daughter I have a bigger chance of deformations in that area). Though the pain was not the nicest thing ever done to me, it was comparable to a heavy period (in other words: I could handle it well enough). And than the radiologist congratulated me: my womb was fine and my *tubes were clear*. I was absolutely flabbergasted. I mean: the past 10 years I was convinced that my tubes were blocked. I actually was a bit pissed off that they wanted me to undergo this painful procedure since it was already so clear that I needed at least a laparoscopy (I can be very stubborn…. fortunately I decided to not tell them till afterwards…..). And now I have these very ambivalent feelings. On one hand I am thrilled that my tubes are all right, on the other I am worried. Blocked tubes was such an easy, detectable cause. Now I am real uncertain about what causes the infertility. But I keep telling myself that I should be really exited and happy, since blocked tubes would most probably be worse. The main feeling I have is still surprise though, because I just was utterly convinced that I knew what was going on. (The Netherlands) This may sound crazy, but my gyn put a bedpan upside-down under my hips for the HSG and it was perfect! It flattened my back against the table so that everything was level and it was easy to maneuver around to get the right angle. She did lie about the pain though…she prompted me about everything except the actual dye injection which was the most painful part! I think the nurse’s hand is still healing. Why is it that every thing I found published about HSGs started out with …”although somewhat painful…” *somewhat*? After the initial pain of the opening of the cervix, I though great this is going pretty well. Then, the dye. My Dr. did not prepare me for this at all. Just said I needed to schedule the procedure. The nurses at the lab were great. I don’t know if they had been through this at all, at least they were more supportive than the male scheduler. Oh well, after the intense pain during the procedure, I didn’t have much more, just a dull ache that finally went away after about 24 - hours (on the way by car to my DH’s 20-year high school reunion). No prescriptions - just Advil. I did find that walking helped in one or two ways: 1) actually eased the pain, or 2) took my mind off of the pain and onto to something else. Either way it’s over. I recently posted the same HSG question & received a tremendous number of responses, good and bad. Last Friday I had my HSG & the worst part about it was the worrying all day long. Once I got to the hospital & changed into the gown, the whole procedure lasted about ten minutes. Some people mentioned things like cervical clamps & Novacaine, & some even recommended asking for a prescription of Valium, so I was a little worried. I took 4 Advil. My doctor inserted the speculum, opened it a little wider than usual, & washed off my cervix with Betadine. He then fed through a very skinny catheter, narrower than a swizzle stick. It was a little uncomfortable, but certainly not painful. Even when the dye was injected, all I felt was a little pressure. He injected the oil based dye once we saw my tube was open, again, just a little pressure. It was definitely worth having done. Now I at least have a little glimmer of hope after my November 95 ectopic. Make sure your RE uses the oil dye - it’s the one that’s supposed to increase chances of pg for three months! My HSG was not too bad either, mind you, not something I would want to repeat! I took 3 Advils 1/2 hour before hand. Had some cramping and slight bleeding afterwards. I was truly terrified after reading some of the posts here. I guess everyone handles pain differently. My doctor performed the procedure which helped me relax even more. Mine (last Monday) was truly a piece of cake. They could do it every week and I wouldn’t mind (except for the time and the cost). I took 2 600 mg Motrin about 1/2 hr before (which isn’t a lot of time for the Motrin to kick in). They numbed my cervix, which was the worst of the pain and when I cramped a little they slowed down and then it was ok. It also was pretty fast. Also, my doc said that the HSG by itself increases fertility (sometimes) if it is the oil kind (not water). I don’t know by what percent but apparently the effect lasts about 6 months. (Obviously this is if everything checks checks out normally, there are eggs and so on.) My HSG was kind of a nightmare. I forgot to take the therapeutic dose of advil that they had recommended to take before the test, and boy did I pay for it! I had cramping for 2 days. Some of it may have been caused from the depression that set in when I found out that both of my tubes were blocked! What was also a horror was when my OB/GYN looked at me, in front of a technician and a nurse and asked me if I ever had chlamidia, ghonareah or any other STD, and said oh, don’t worry they are doing amazing things with IVF. I was horrified! No, I’ve never had any of those diseases and I was shocked that she would ask me that in front of other people. I had to be consoled by the nurse who said that it could because my tubes cramped up or something else. Anyhow, the one good thing that came out of it was she recommended me to see my RE, who is wonderful! I also started doing some research and found out that tubes can be blocked by just about anything, including appendicitis, which I had in 1993. My appendix was gangrenous and was within hours of exploding. Will having a hysterosalpingogram effect my chances of getting pregnant? If so why and for how long? Supposedly an HSG can increase your chances of getting pregnant for the first 3 cycles after the procedure. I’ve seen some people say it ups your odds of success per cycle to about 30% because it “blows out the cobwebs” in the tubes. Yes, it worked for me! The first time I got pregnant was 2 months after an HSG (which showed the tubes were clear) and the second time the month after my LAP (where they also insert dye into your tubes - tubes were still open). Those were the only 2 times I was pregnant. Unfortunately the first pregnancy ended in miscarriage and the second one was an ectopic (so there must be something wrong with my tubes after all), but what matters is that pregnancy really does happen more frequently after an HSG. (Portugal) Yep, our little guy was conceived the same month that I had the HSG. I researched it and found that studies had shown a significant number of women who had HSG became pregnant within the next few months. They were unsure why - speculation ran from it cleared out small blockages to it changed the ph level in some way. My RE told me when I had my HSG 2 years ago that the reason why it makes you more fertile afterwards is because the dye makes the cilia stand up and therefore is able to grasp the egg and make it travel easier down the tube. |
| Sonohysterogram / Saline Ultrasound $400-$607 |
| Hysteroscopy - $755-$4,002 |
| Laparoscopy - $1,700-$5,500 |
| Dilation & Curretage $200-$1000 |
What is a dilation & curettage and why is it needed? A dilation and curettage begins with dilating the cervix to about the width of a ballpoint pen. Through the opening, an instrument shaped like a small garden hoe with a vacuum tube attached is inserted. The uterus is both scraped and vacuumed The procedure is often done in conjunction with a hysteroscopy, or to resolve a miscarriage. What should I expect when I have a dilation & curettage? How will it feel? I had a D&C in December 2000 because of an incomplete miscarriage. It was done at the hospital where my IF clinic is located. It was outpatient surgery and I recovered very quickly. We had to be at the hospital two hours before the surgery. I couldn’t eat or drink anything after midnight the night before. After registering and getting a wrist band, I was brought into pre-op, where I changed into a gown (which was plenty big enough, even though I’m 265 lbs), got settled in a bed, and went through my history with the nurses. They asked about previous surgeries and any complications. A phlebotomist came in and started an IV in my forearm. A nurse started an antibiotic drip and asked me to let them know if I experienced any itching or dizziness (apparently an allergic response to the antibiotic). An anesthesia nurse came in and discussed the anesthesia with me. They also started a saline drip, which unfortunately generally has the effect of making me having to go to the bathroom a lot (which is a pain when you’re in a gown, dragging an IV pole). I was pretty emotional during all of this and the nurses were kind about it. After a while, a transport person came and moved me (on my bed) up to the surgery waiting area. A nurse came by, checked my wrist band, and reviewed the procedure with me. Then the surgeon came by, checked my band, and reviewed everything with me again. Everyone was very careful about checking and keeping us informed. My husband was with me while I waited. Eventually, they moved me off to the operating room. The OR was very large, cold, with a high ceiling and bright lights. I had to move from my bed to the OR bed, which was a pain what with all the blankets, the IV line (which got caught between the beds), etc. Once I was on the OR bed, everything moved very quickly. There was an anesthesia doctor, the surgeon, and two nurses. The surgeon spread my legs and placed each on a thigh rest — quite comfortable. The anesthesiologist said he would give me something to relax me. He put it in the IV and I immediately started feeling a bit woozy and sort of woolly. Next thing I knew, I was waking up as they wheeled me out of the OR. In past surgeries, it’s taken a long time for me to wake up and lose the grogginess, but this time I was awake and aware right away. I spent about 45 minutes in recovery and was completely awake the whole time. I had a heart and blood pressure monitor hooked up — the BP monitor inflated every 10 minutes or so to check my BP. The nurse checked me frequently and also checked if I was bleeding. The surgeon had put a sanitary napkin and belt on me, which felt a little funny when I woke up. An orderly came and wheeled the bed back up to outpatient surgery and my husband was there. The nurse gave me some juice and crackers, which stayed down fine. I’ve had trouble with nausea after anesthesia in the past, which I had told them before the surgery so they gave me some meds to counteract the nausea. I was able to get up within a few minutes and walk to the bathroom. I was a little bloody and my entire crotch (I hate that word!) had been swabbed with betadyne (an antiseptic) which was kind of sticky and disconcerting. I had no pain when I went to the bathroom. I got dressed right after that and we left. I felt OK — a little weak and tired and some minor cramps. The doctor said not to shower or bathe for 24 hours after the surgery. I stayed home from work the next day but really felt fine. I bled very lightly for about a week after the surgery. I had my D&C 1 week ago today(on friday), the procedure went very well. I got to the hospital at 10:30AM and signed in, at 11:00AM I was taken to the outpatient presurgical waiting area. I was given a gown to change into that was generously large on me, and I weigh 285 pounds. I was then given a gurney to lay on, the anesthesiologist came to talk with me and it was decided that it would be easier on my body to just sedate me with twilight sedation. I would be awake but would have no idea what was going on. After I talked to the anesthesiologist, he put my IV in for me. I told him I was a little anxious about the procedure and he told me he would give me some Versed to calm me down a little. After putting the med in my IV, it took about 2 minutes until I was happy and feeling relaxed. At 12:30, they took me to the OR. Once in the room, they had me get myself from the gurney to the table. I remember them getting my arms on little extensions that they strapped them to and giving me a little more meds. After that I remember nothing except that I became kind of awake during the very end of the procedure, at which time they gave me a little more medication. The next thing I remember is them asking if I could transfer myself back to the gurney and I was able to do that. I was awake and alert from that point on. I went home at about 2:00, 45 minutes after the procedure ended. I was a little tired and weak and rested up over the weekend and returned to work on Monday. I spotted on and off for 5 days, but that has ended now. I was also told not to lift or strain for 1 week, and when I did I had some twinging type pains and increased bleeding. I work at a daycare center and it is kind of hard to not do any lifting. Otherwise my D&C was very easy and probably a lot easier than a lot of the procedures that we endure for infertility. I don’t know how helpful my stories will be, but I have had 4 D and C’s in eight months and each one was different. D and C number 1: This was the first D and C I have ever had and I was scared out of my wits. I have asthma and actually went into an attack prior to the surgery! After respiratory therapy came down to administer a treatment I was ready. The nurses were very kind, but most did not know that I had a mc. I guess the D and C procedure is pretty common. In fact, I have heard it referred to as a Dusting and Cleaning. I was given a heavy sedation instead of general anesthesia, as i tend to vomit after general. I cried as they wheeled me into the operating room. I was scared and sad. My doctor did not do much to comfort me, but the nurses did. The room was very cold and they placed warm blankets on me to warm me up. I don’t remember falling asleep. Upon waking I felt fine–a bit crampy, but only mild. I was in post-op for an hour and in my room for and hour and then drove home. The worst part was just the emotional aspect of the loss. I was told no intercourse or baths for 2 weeks. I took ibuprofen for cramps. When AF started 34 days later it was heavy and painful, not like my usual experience with AF, which had tapered off to just 3 days and light flow. D and C number 2 was also for a mc. I went to the doctor’s office knowing that the hcg levels did not rise and the doctor “squeezed” me into his afternoon schedule. I was not as nervous and not as sad, as I had no chance to get emotional about this pregnancy. Again, I had the twilight sleep and drifted off. I even joked with the staff in the OR, saying that I would rather not rack up frequent flyer miles. Woke up, ate, went home. Two days later I was in excruciating pain and had a script for Darvocet phoned in. I was in severe pain for three days over the Thanksgiving holiday. I wondered if the doctor had scraped too hard. I never felt such abdominal pain. D and C number 3 was again for a mc. I was 10 weeks along. This time I had been released by my RE doctor and was in my home town getting prenatal care from my OB. She was very kind and compassionate, as she had experienced the same thing twice before, the last time just weeks before this last loss. I cried and cried–I was in shock. It was pretty similar to the other two done in a large city hospital–cold room, warm blankets. Except the anesthesiologist used a general anesthesia despite my request not to and I did vomit–nasty stuff. I bled and bled–then passed large pieces of tissue for the next week and experienced a lot of pain. I called the OB’s office but I think that they chalked it up to my being emotional from the loss. Finally on day 6 I had another ultrasound which showed material left in the uterus. I had D and C number 4 one week after number three. Finally after number 4 I stopped bleeding and cramping. I know that the OB wa concerned about not scraping too hard and I think that she felt very badly for missing what turned out to be the rest of the placenta. I have had gall bladder surgery and a laproscopy, as well as a hernia repair. The D and C procedure was m |

